Magic Formula Stocks Part 3
Whenever I am in search for undervalued stocks, the
magic formula website is the number one place to visit. Where else can I find a screen that a) measures stocks on valuation and b) gives me solid businesses.
One thing I have noticed about the magic formula screen is, as the market moves higher the quality of businesses decreases. Also, as the market moves lower, the quality of businesses increase. Let me explain. When the market was making new highs (remember 14,000?), I recognized few if any stocks on the list and had to do a lot more reading to be well informed on what company “x” is doing, its future plans, etc… This is how I discovered Accenture (ACN) which I sold at $34 and is now at $40 (see image)
. Now the markets are in bear market territory and some familiar names are appearing. When running the magic formula screen, I use the top 25 results for the following market caps: 50, 250, 500, 1000, 2000. This way I am able to see which stocks appear the most. For example, a company like Perini Corp. (PCR) appears in the magic formula screen (top 25) for the 50, 250, 500 million minimum market cap. Obviously, for Perini to show in 3 of the screens it must be ranked high. Also, I ran the 700 mill minimum market cap screen and it appears there.
50 Million Market Caps - Top 100
American Eagle Outfitters (AEO)- The stock of this popular teen retailer tanked after its chief marketing officer resigned bringing the stock to some historic low levels. Be careful though, company has auction rate securities (ARS) on hand which it might have to write down or take a write off. When and if it does, stock may go down providing an opporturnity. I established a small position on that basis.
Barrett Business Services (BBSI)- My favorite among the staffing companies (there are many on the magic formula list). Obviously, its been beaten down as less people are hired during recessions. Also, temporary workers are usually the first to get the boot in bad times as companies downsize to keep expenses down as revenue decline or stay flat. One has to love a CEO who tells Wall St “If you guys want to sell [the company] down to five times earnings, maybe I will just buy the whole [expletive] thing.” The company has $5 in cash.
Boeing Co. (BA)- Nice backlog but cannot get a plane off the ground. At these levels, I am interested and might establish a position.
Coach Inc. (COH)- Their bags are expensive, yet women love them.
Frontier OIl Corp. (FTO)- Best of breed refiner suffering due to low (negative?) refining margins. Any increase in the spread would really help this company.
FreightCar America (RAIL)- Haven’t really checked the story but I know it has been talked about in the value investing community.
Gannett Co. Inc. (GCI)- Declining industry, stay away. A.K.A. Value Trap
Hansen Natural Corp (HANS)- Their MONSTER Drinks might not be selling like before but company has other great drinks. Might be worth investigating.
Herman Miller (MLHR)- The maker of office furniture (known for their Aeron chair) showed up on my screen today. I’m impressed with their ability to continue results despite a weak U.S marker. Their management has given analysts nothing to chew on in the guidance front and I like it. I get the feeling that management is telling analysts “Do your homework”. Anyway, the company is doing a great job of getting their products in front of customers and selling on quality, quick delivery, etc. A pretty straight forward plan for success.
Lear Corp. (LEA)- Struggles as long as auto industry struggles. Any rebound in auto sales will help company.
Manitowac Company (MTW)-Now, I have spent a good deal of time reading their statements. Thesis is simple: the company continues to expand globally but is getting pounded due to its domestic operations. Its Crane division might be worth more than its current market cap. The company is doing a fine job of expanding into India and China. Now, if the US Market recovers (which it will) its stock price can really run.
McGraw-Hill Companies Inc (MHP)- The maker of textbooks and owner of Standard and Poor’s has been beaten down for some reason, might be due to its S&P division but not sure. I read a while back their textbook sales in decline mode, but with me paying $100+ for a textbook I can see why
NVIDIA (NVDA)- Stock tanked 30% on Friday. Not in circle of compence
Perini Corp. (PCR)- Slowdown? What slowdown? You wouldn’t know there was a slowdown by reading their reports. The company has a 7 billion+ backlog and is planning to expand into Dubai and other foreign countries.
Premier Exhibitions (PRXI)- Interesting company as it deals with museum exhibition of the Titanic (something along those line).
These are the type of companies and stories you can find while the market is down. For a company to like Boeing (BA) to appear on the list using such a low market cap screen is interesting. I am 99% confident it will appear in the rest of the screens, in which I will make different post. Now, by no means is this a final list of companies to look into. The list above only mentions 15 out of the 100 companies that appeared using a minimum market cap of 50 million and 100 results. The other companies I have either mentioned before (ACN,PACR,etc..) or have not looked into as I usually look into the top 25.
I wanted to comment on the other screens (250, 500, 1000, 2000) but the article was getting a little lengthy so I am going to break them into pieces.
Disclosure: I own AEO, MTW, PCR, BBSI, MLHR
If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!
- July 5th
[...] Flying Under The Radar Jul.05, 2008 in Value Investing In the previous article I mentioned how it was kind of odd that Boeing appeared in the top 100 results for companies with a [...]
Hi,
We appear to follow same rules of investing ie value investing and given that you have two stocks (one that you hold which I sold) and one that you are considering (that I bought)here is my perspective on my reasons as to my actions.
Sold Manitowoc at $41 (loss of $3) - on basis of “diworsification”.I bought due to their leadership in cranes during the current infrastructure boom but their decision to buy Enodis at a significant premium to Enodis market valuation,a maker of restaurant equipment to dilute Manitowoc’s exposure to cranes signalled that my original reason for buying Manitowoc was no longer was valid.If you read Peter Lynch ‘One Up on Wall Street’,you will understand what diworsification means to shareholders.
Bought Hansen at 28.5- very well managed business and given its turnover is still only $1 billion,has plenty of room to grow particularly internationally where it is still relatively unknown.I don’t expect its earnings to grow as fast as in the past but I believe the margin of safety at such a price,presents a compelling buying opportunity for a strong business.